you are the girl next door
too bad you're not next door to me
she is one i adore
too bad she's just not right for me

the way she wouldn't looked at me
left me searching for something new
the way you looked at me
made sure i fell in love with two

whoa, i took too long to let her know
whoa, and now this song is not her own

(Chorus) searching for Katie
i stumbled on you
what a world i'm living in
when my odds times two
searching for Katie
i stumbled on you
what a world i'm living in
when my odds times two

hey look, i'm nervous now
i need to tell you fast somehow
just blew my second chance
maybe my third will be my last

last chance! i'm nervous now
been played out on the radio
i can't let go of you
can i be everything you want?

whoa, so now i'm glad you let me know
whoa, and now I'll never let you go

(Chorus)

whoa, now that I have let her go
whoa, this song is now your own

(Chorus x2)